• Directories
    • Business Directory
    • Church Directory
    • Organization Directory
  • Advertise
  • Donate
  • Help
  • Log In
MENUMENU
  • Learning
        • Leader’s Edge
          • Author Interviews
          • Book Summaries
        • Book Reviews
          • Book Look
          • EMQ Book Reviews
        • Publications
          • Anthology
          • Evangelical Missions Quarterly (EMQ)
          • Missiographics
        • Podcasts
          • The Mission MattersNew
          • Missio Nexus
          • People First HR
          • Members Only Feed
        • Blogs
          • Global Issues Updates
          • Member Highlights
          • Mission Advisors
        • Topics
          • COVID-19 ResourcesNew
          • Diaspora Missions
          • Mobilization
          • Muslim Missions
          • Support Raising
        • Media Library
          • Conferences
          • Global Issue Updates
          • On Mission
          • Thought Leader Briefings
          • Webinars
          • Workshop
          • View All
  • Programs
    • Accreditation
    • Alliance for Benefits
    • Bible CertificateNew
    • Church Missions CoachingNew
    • Cohorts
    • Cybersecurity
    • Emerging Leaders
    • Mission Jobs
    • OnBoard
    • RightNow Media
    • The Mission AppNew
    • Women’s Development
  • Events
          • Calendar
          • In-Person Events
          • Virtual Events
          • Event Recordings
          • Awards
        • Upcoming Events

          • Webinar: Through the Wall
            Thu Jan 28 2021, 02:00pm EST
          • Three Easy Ways to Drive Innovation
            Thu Feb 11 2021, 02:00pm EST
          • Three Steps to Kickstart Your Fund Development Program
            Tue Feb 16 2021, 03:00pm EST
        • View All Events
  • Research
          • Missiographics
          • Mission Handbook
          • Research Reports
        • Popular Research
          • Compensation Reports
          • COVID-19 ResourcesNew
          • Field Attrition Report
          • View All Reports
        • Contribute
          • Current Research Projects
          • Submit Data for Mission Handbook
          • Volunteer
  • About Us
        • Who We Are
          • Our Contribution
          • Meet the Team
          • Board Members
          • History (1917–present)
        • Our Beliefs
          • Statement of Faith
          • Community Standards
        • Awards
        • Partner with Us
          • Advertise
          • Donate
          • Sponsorships
          • Volunteer
        • Help
          • Contact Us
          • Advertising Specs
          • Branding Guidelines
  • Join
        • Learn
        • Learn what you cannot learn anywhere else.

        • Meet
        • Meet people you otherwise won’t meet.

        • Engage
        • Engage in a community like none other.

          • Benefits
          • Benefits for Churches
          • Pricing

Sponsored Content

Upcoming Events

  • Webinar: Through the Wall
    Thu Jan 28 2021, 02:00pm EST
  • Three Easy Ways to Drive Innovation
    Thu Feb 11 2021, 02:00pm EST
  • Three Steps to Kickstart Your Fund Development Program
    Tue Feb 16 2021, 03:00pm EST
  • Webinar: Innovating Theological Education: How BibleMesh can Prepare your Staff for Ministry
    Thu Feb 25 2021, 02:00pm EST
  • Association Leaders Gathering
    Tue Mar 2 2021, 08:30am EST

View all events »

Topics

author interview Canada CEO Church Church Missions Church Mission Team Church Planting Coaching Conference Proceedings COVID-19 Cross Cultural Skills Diaspora Evangelism Focus Future Globally Engaged Churches Islam Justin Long Leadership Management Missiology Missionaries Mission Finance and Administration MLC2019 MLC2020 Mobilization muslim Muslim Diaspora Networks Partnership Personal Productivity Podcast Presenter Research Security Short-Term Missions Spirituality support raising Training Trends Unengaged Unreached unreached people groups Weekly Roundup Women

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Complexities of Money and Missions in Asia

Posted on October 1, 2012 by October 1, 2012

by Paul H. De Neui, editor

SEANET Series, vol. 9. William Carey Library, 1605 E. Elizabeth Street, Pasadena, CA 91104, 2012, xiv+156 pages, $15.99.

—Reviewed by Edwin R. Zehner, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Westmont College, Santa Barbara, California.

This volume asks what levels of missionary living and organizational expenditure best aid effectiveness while avoiding dependency and overly lavish operations. It also asks how to address cross-cultural value differences between mission and church partners. Although primarily referencing Sri Lanka, Thailand, and Cambodia, the discussions potentially have broader relevance.

In the volume, G.P.V. Somaratne notes Sri Lankan Buddhists’ concerns that Christians’ greater access to outside financial resources gives them an unfair advantage in competing for adherents. OMF missionary Alex Smith, referencing experiences in Thailand, illustrates that local cultural patterns must be kept in mind when deciding on personal charitable outlays. He also shares why consultation with local cultural brokers may be necessary when making these decisions, and that sometimes the roles most appropriate for missionaries are different from those played by local cultural patrons.

Mary Lederleitner highlights the complexities of negotiating expectations across culture and class boundaries. She calls for a process of “sharing deeply, suspending judgment, and listening” in such a way that “the whole of a situation can be brought into the open, and practitioners can begin to grasp their [ministry] partner’s experiences and context” (p. 99). David Lim similarly calls for an atmosphere of mutuality and for “the willingness of each [partner] to plan, budget, and discuss all matters openly and honestly” (p. 139). By contrast, Paul De Neui discusses traditional patron-client systems as potential models for ministry. His suggestion overlaps Smith’s mention of potential clientele expectations (e.g., p. 34), but with some important differences.

I agree with De Neui and Smith on keeping culture in mind; however, doing so raises complexities. For example, the honest mutuality urged by Lederleitner and Lim may fit westerners’ expectations better than the more indirect style preferred by local partners. Also, I join Smith in urging caution when taking on patron-client relationships, even though they are often at the heart of how church-mission relations work.

In Thailand, hierarchical ministry relations often involve hopes for reliable ministerial and instructional support rather than simply desires for money. Therefore, just as Smith notes on the personal level (see p. 34), local churches often expect overseas partner-benefactors to commit long term. Such partners should also distinguish their support from attempts to control, as only the former is culturally appropriate. Finally, cultural outsiders should take special care that changes in support are truly negotiated since local partners may be culturally unaccustomed to stating their expectations directly (see p. 102).

There is potential to take all these discussions much further. It would be nice, for example, to hear the voices of more Asian church leaders, even if via translation of oral remarks. It would also be beneficial to see interview and survey data exploring local leaders’ perceptions of mission lifestyles, asking how unequal access to external funding may be affecting local relations, and investigating ways that local churches are responding to such issues. Many Asian Christians and resident missionaries already have the skills to pursue such questions. Perhaps the results will appear in future SEANET volumes.

Check these titles:
Kumalo, Simangaliso. 2011. “Missions Are Money and Money Is Missions: Methodist Ecclesiology in South Africa, 1872–2004.” Studia Historiae Ecclesiasticae 37(2): 1–17. Open-source peer-reviewed journal hosted by the University of South Africa. Accessed May 15, 2012, from http://uir.unisa.ac.za/handle/10500/5123.
Lederleitner, Mary. 2010. Cross-cultural Partnerships: Navigating the Complexities of Money and Mission. Downers Grove, Ill.: InterVarsity Press.
Wilson, Douglas O. 2004. Field Statement #1 Submitted to Dr. Priest in the Form of a Course Syllabus on Missions and Money. Developed as part of graduate coursework at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School. Accessed May 15, 2012, from http://web.tiu.edu/files/divinity/academics/programs/phd/ics/missionsmoney.pdf.

….

EMQ, Vol. 48, No. 4, pp. 500-503. Copyright  © 2012 Evangelism and Missions Information Service (EMIS).  All rights reserved. Not to be reproduced or copied in any form without written permission from EMIS.

 

GoToOlder PostNewer PostAll PostsBook ReviewsEMQSectionVolume 48 - Issue 4

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to Our Mailing List

Keep up to date with our community.

Menu

  • Join
  • Directories
  • Events
  • Donate

About

  • Who We Are
  • Statement of Faith
  • Awards
  • Resources

Help

  • Contact Us
  • Terms
  • Cookies Policy

Connect

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Google+

PO Box 398
Wheaton, IL 60187-0398

Phone: 770.457.6677
678.392.4577

© Missio Nexus.
All Rights Reserved.

Membership website powered by MembershipWorks