• Directories
    • Business Directory
    • Church Directory
    • Organization Directory
  • Advertise
  • Donate
  • Help
  • Log In
MENUMENU
  • Learning
        • Leader’s Edge
          • Author Interviews
          • Book Summaries
        • Book Reviews
          • Book Look
          • EMQ Book Reviews
        • Publications
          • Anthology
          • Evangelical Missions Quarterly (EMQ)
          • Missiographics
        • Podcasts
          • The Mission MattersNew
          • Missio Nexus
          • People First HR
          • Members Only Feed
        • Blogs
          • Global Issues Updates
          • Member Highlights
          • Mission Advisors
        • Topics
          • COVID-19 ResourcesNew
          • Diaspora Missions
          • Mobilization
          • Muslim Missions
          • Support Raising
        • Media Library
          • Conferences
          • Global Issue Updates
          • On Mission
          • Thought Leader Briefings
          • Webinars
          • Workshop
          • View All
  • Programs
    • Accreditation
    • Alliance for Benefits
    • Bible CertificateNew
    • Church Missions CoachingNew
    • Cohorts
    • Cybersecurity
    • Emerging Leaders
    • Mission Jobs
    • OnBoard
    • RightNow Media
    • The Mission AppNew
    • Women’s Development
  • Events
          • Calendar
          • In-Person Events
          • Virtual Events
          • Event Recordings
          • Awards
        • Upcoming Events

          • Webinar: Through the Wall
            Thu Jan 28 2021, 02:00pm EST
          • Three Easy Ways to Drive Innovation
            Thu Feb 11 2021, 02:00pm EST
          • Three Steps to Kickstart Your Fund Development Program
            Tue Feb 16 2021, 03:00pm EST
        • View All Events
  • Research
          • Missiographics
          • Mission Handbook
          • Research Reports
        • Popular Research
          • Compensation Reports
          • COVID-19 ResourcesNew
          • Field Attrition Report
          • View All Reports
        • Contribute
          • Current Research Projects
          • Submit Data for Mission Handbook
          • Volunteer
  • About Us
        • Who We Are
          • Our Contribution
          • Meet the Team
          • Board Members
          • History (1917–present)
        • Our Beliefs
          • Statement of Faith
          • Community Standards
        • Awards
        • Partner with Us
          • Advertise
          • Donate
          • Sponsorships
          • Volunteer
        • Help
          • Contact Us
          • Advertising Specs
          • Branding Guidelines
  • Join
        • Learn
        • Learn what you cannot learn anywhere else.

        • Meet
        • Meet people you otherwise won’t meet.

        • Engage
        • Engage in a community like none other.

          • Benefits
          • Benefits for Churches
          • Pricing

Sponsored Content

Upcoming Events

  • Webinar: Through the Wall
    Thu Jan 28 2021, 02:00pm EST
  • Three Easy Ways to Drive Innovation
    Thu Feb 11 2021, 02:00pm EST
  • Three Steps to Kickstart Your Fund Development Program
    Tue Feb 16 2021, 03:00pm EST
  • Webinar: Innovating Theological Education: How BibleMesh can Prepare your Staff for Ministry
    Thu Feb 25 2021, 02:00pm EST
  • Association Leaders Gathering
    Tue Mar 2 2021, 08:30am EST

View all events »

Topics

author interview Canada CEO Church Church Missions Church Mission Team Church Planting Coaching Conference Proceedings COVID-19 Cross Cultural Skills Diaspora Evangelism Focus Future Globally Engaged Churches Islam Justin Long Leadership Management Missiology Missionaries Mission Finance and Administration MLC2019 MLC2020 Mobilization muslim Muslim Diaspora Networks Partnership Personal Productivity Podcast Presenter Research Security Short-Term Missions Spirituality support raising Training Trends Unengaged Unreached unreached people groups Weekly Roundup Women

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Telling the Difference

Posted on July 1, 2004 by July 1, 2004

by Gary Corwin

There is a need for more objective criteria to assess when contextualization has crossed the line into syncretism.

What’s the rule-of-thumb definition for the difference between contextualization and syncretism? Simple: it’s contextualization when I do it, but syncretism when you do it!

If that sounds facetious, it was meant to. But discussion on this issue does often reside at the level of subjective feeling rather than objective standards.

In recent years new contextualization scales have described various approaches for penetrating Muslim and Hindu cultures with the gospel. Those scales frame much of the discussion on best strategies for mission in those contexts. The debates they have generated point to the need for more objective criteria to assess when contextualization has crossed the line into syncretism.

The answer lies, I believe, in clarifying our assumptions and definitions. To get the ball rolling, I propose these important assumptions:

1. God loves cultural diversity and established it for our good (to hinder our tendency to rebel against him).

2. No culture is neutral—all are subject to divine judgment for their conformity or lack thereof to God’s revealed will.

3. The church is (or ought to be) God’s counter-culture within any culture—affirming that which harmonizes with his revealed will, and contrasting starkly with what does not.

4. Contextualization occurs when the church in a culture gets this right; syncretism when it does not.

What about definitions? Shades of degree for both contextualization and syncretism make this tricky because a spectrum of subtle differences exists. The spectrum ranges from highly effective contextualization, to less serious forms of syncretism (which also means less effective contextualization), to syncretism in its most detrimental forms. Because our own cultural assumptions and values are almost invisible to us, the church in any culture tends to be blind much more to its own compromises than to others.

Five questions can help us to understand the subtleties in a society:

1. What biblical practices or mandates are often over-emphasized to either good or bad effect? The least harmful type of failure is to overly emphasize an otherwise excellent activity or focus. For example, legalisms are developed to enforce how often or long a person prays, simply because that culture tends to set standards for such practices.

2. What cultural assumptions significantly impact for good or ill the gospel’s incarnation? These assumptions tend to be widely accepted and almost invisible to those who hold them. In the USA, for example, assumptions about progress and rugged individualism affect our ecclesiology. One result is that Christians tend to separate from those with whom they disagree, and start their own churches in order to achieve or maintain theological purity.

Such beliefs are not inherently bad or totally lacking as reflections of spiritual truth, but failing to recognize them as cultural assumptions obscures larger and more balanced understandings of spiritual truth.

3. Is the gospel’s essence as the Bible presents it fully embraced by the church? This critical focus area addresses matters of content, for example, to whom we should pray, or what we should pray about. (The issue of content is more serious when it involves the trappings of the culture’s dominant religion.)

4. Is anything added to the gospel? An important distinction within the content area arises over the difference between how eternal truth is received, and what in a culture may appropriately co-exist with eternal truth. The first instance distinguishes between how gospel truth is presented and interpreted properly or improperly within the particular culture. In the second, the question is how truth claims from within the culture are embraced or rejected based on their compatibility with the gospel. The appeal of a prosperity gospel in Western cultures might be a syncretistic example of the former, and ancestor veneration in an Asian or African culture might exemplify the latter.

5. Does the typical church and believer remind people of Jesus or simply of any good citizen? Issues of practice are most visible, and therefore likely to gain the most attention. However, they may be either more or less important than content issues, depending on whether the practices are a conscious response to previous decisions about content, or an unconscious habit not yet thoroughly examined in this light.

The key question for any church is whether it is a haven and breeding ground for individual disciples who are genuinely born from above.

Where does such an understanding of all these subtleties leave us? I believe with some simple but important tools for examining the seriousness of the contextualization/syncretism issues in any setting. Every issue—whether a matter of emphasis, assumption, belief or practice—falls somewhere along that category’s seriousness spectrum. And each category, from emphasis to practice, is itself increasingly more serious. The farther along either spectrum that we go, therefore, the greater the potential risks and rewards are, and the more care we must take. Let’s make sure we treat these issues with the great caution and boldness they require.

Gary Corwin is associate editor of Evangelical Missions Quarterly and a special representative with SIM in Charlotte, N.C.

EMQ, Vol. 40, No. 3, pp. 282-283. Copyright © 2004 Evangelism and Missions Information Service (EMIS). All rights reserved. Not to be reproduced or copied in any form without written permission from EMIS.

GoToOlder PostNewer PostAll PostsA Second Look: Editorial by EMQ Editor Gary CorwinEMQSectionVolume 40 - Issue 3

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to Our Mailing List

Keep up to date with our community.

Menu

  • Join
  • Directories
  • Events
  • Donate

About

  • Who We Are
  • Statement of Faith
  • Awards
  • Resources

Help

  • Contact Us
  • Terms
  • Cookies Policy

Connect

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Google+

PO Box 398
Wheaton, IL 60187-0398

Phone: 770.457.6677
678.392.4577

© Missio Nexus.
All Rights Reserved.

Membership website powered by MembershipWorks