• Directories
    • Business Directory
    • Church Directory
    • Organization Directory
  • Advertise
  • Donate
  • Help
  • Log In

MENUMENU
  • Learning
        • Leader’s Edge
          • Author Interviews
          • Book Summaries
        • Book Reviews
          • Book Look
          • EMQ Book Reviews
        • Publications
          • Anthology
          • Evangelical Missions Quarterly (EMQ)
          • Missiographics
        • Podcasts
          • The Mission Matters
          • Members Only Feed
          • Missions Podcast DirectoryNew
        • Topics
          • COVID-19 Resources
          • Diaspora Missions
          • Global Issues Updates
          • Member Highlights
          • Mobilization
          • Muslim Missions
          • Support Raising
          • UkraineNew
        • Media Library
          • Conferences
          • Global Issue Updates
          • On Mission
          • Thought Leader Briefings
          • Webinars
          • Workshop
          • View All
  • Programs
    • Accreditation
    • Bible Certificate
    • Church Missions Coaching
    • Cohorts
    • Cybersecurity
    • ImproveNew
    • Mission Jobs
    • Missions DataNew
    • Publish
    • RightNow Media
    • The Mission App
    • Women’s Development
  • Events
          • Calendar
          • In-Person Events
          • Virtual Events
          • Event Recordings
          • Awards
        • Premier Events
          • Mission Leaders Conference
          • On Mission
        • Upcoming Events

          • Webinar: An Introduction to the Theology and Practice of Cross-Cultural Risk
            Thu May 26 2022, 12:00pm EDT
          • Pocket Guide to Being a Missions Pastor: 5 Things Every Missions Pastor Needs to Know
            Wed Jun 1 2022, 01:00pm EDT
          • From Harlem to the World - the Local Church Mobilized for Global Missions
            Wed Aug 3 2022, 01:00pm EDT
        • View All Events
  • Research
          • Missions DataNew
          • Missiographics
          • Research Reports
        • Popular Research
          • Compensation Reports
          • COVID-19 Resources
          • Field Attrition Report
          • View All Reports
        • Contribute
          • Current Research Projects
          • Volunteer
  • About Us
        • Who We Are
          • Our Contribution
          • Meet the Team
          • Board Members
          • History (1917–present)
        • Our Beliefs
          • Statement of Faith
          • Community Standards
        • Awards
        • Partner with Us
          • Advertise
          • Donate
          • Sponsorships
          • Volunteer
        • Help
          • Contact Us
          • Advertising Specs
          • Branding Guidelines
  • Join
        • Learn
        • Learn what you cannot learn anywhere else.

        • Meet
        • Meet people you otherwise won’t meet.

        • Engage
        • Engage in a community like none other.

          • Benefits
          • Benefits for Churches
          • Pricing

Sponsored Content

Upcoming Events

  • Webinar: An Introduction to the Theology and Practice of Cross-Cultural Risk
    Thu May 26 2022, 12:00pm EDT
  • Pocket Guide to Being a Missions Pastor: 5 Things Every Missions Pastor Needs to Know
    Wed Jun 1 2022, 01:00pm EDT
  • From Harlem to the World - the Local Church Mobilized for Global Missions
    Wed Aug 3 2022, 01:00pm EDT
  • Innovation Leaders Discussion
    Mon Aug 8 2022, 01:00pm EDT
  • Peer 2 Peer for Communications and Marketing Staff: Communications and the Mission of God: Aligning organizational communications with God's purposes
    Thu Aug 18 2022, 01:00pm EDT

View all events »

Topics

author interview CEO Church Church Missions Church Mission Team Church Planting COVID-19 Cross Cultural Skills Diaspora Disciple Making Discipleship Focus Future Innovation Islam Justin Long Leadership Management Member Care Missiology Missionaries Mission Finance and Administration MLC2019 MLC2020 MLC2021 Mobilization muslim Muslim Diaspora Networks Partnership Podcast Presenter Pursuing Partnerships Series Research Risk Short-Term Missions Spirituality support raising Training Trends Unengaged Unreached Weekly Roundup Women Women in Leadership

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Missions under Attack: Risking Hard Questions about Our Empires

Posted on October 1, 1983 by Ted EslerOctober 1, 1983

by Jim Reapsome

Fishers of men or founders of empire? is a question all missionaries have to face in their work.

Fishers of men or founders of empire? is a question all missionaries have to face in their work. No doubt we all start out as fishers of men, but as the fishing goes on it gets more complicated. Not many of us are content to fish for trout with a safety pin tied to a piece of string wrapped around a stick. Likewise, in missionary work, we soon find better ways to fish for men. Before long, the actual fishing requires elaborate, expensive, sophisticated equipment and a huge support base. To the outsider, it’s not the fishing he sees, but the apparatus that is required for the fisherman to do his work. The "empire" obscures the fishing.

It would be interesting, and perhaps embarrassing, for us to look at our missionary enterprises the way an outsider does. The book written about Wycliffe Bible Translators/Summer Institute of Linguistics by David Stoll, Fishers of Men or Founders of Empire? (reviewed in this issue by William Kornfield) shows what happens when an outsider digs into our work. The result is not flattering; worse, it is angering.

When such a critical book is written about missionaries, our reflex action is self-defense. We point out the flaws and the biases in the book; we try to explain what we have done and why. We feel like we are suffering for righteousness’ sake.

Suddenly, we find ourselves defending the empire we have built around our fishing. The empire becomes the issue, not the fishing. Or, to put it another way, public relations becomes the issue, the possible loss of donor support, a possible drop in recruits, or worst of all, possible eviction from our fishing grounds (the host country).

Missionary work does involve all of those legitimate concerns, but those are empire concerns. We must keep clearly in mind that empires come and go. Perhaps our own empire must crash so that better fishing can be done in the future. Look at the mighty crash of missionary empires in China 34 years ago. Now it appears that the fishing is better than it has ever been, without any foreign empires at all.

So, the question does make us examine what we are doing with our own lives and the lives of people who have committed themselves to our missionary empires. It also makes us look again at our fishing and at our catch. How many fish do we really have to show for the millions of dollars faithful givers are pouring into our empires?

There is no price tag on a soul, of course. It’s possible to film-flam people with reports of so many conversions per dollar. That is not the issue here. The issue is whether or not we are prepared to keep our superstructures from overpowering the fishing. Can we keep our missionary forces in fighting trim, so to speak, and thus reduce as much as possible the charge that missionary work is just a cover for religious empire-building and imperialism?

Critics will always say that. Nevertheless, our response must be a clear conscience and good behavior (1 Pet. 3:16). We can’t stop critics from publishing derogatory books, but we must be sure that in our zeal to fish for men we do not follow earthly policies and adopt earthly ways of fishing. The rightness of soul winning and church building must never be used to justify any kind of duplicity or subterfuge. The Great Commission must never be a cover for building a religious business.

The value of a book like Stoll’s is that it makes us check the procedures, appearances, strategies and costs of our missionary empires. It also makes us check our motives before God and men. Our money and our motives are going to be questioned and criticized as never before, because of the explosive economic and political world scene. Missionaries will not be spared. They will continue to be suspected as agents of the West, with unlimited resources spawned by a capitalism that in itself is seen as the prime cause of the world’s ills.

These boiling problems do make our fishing much more complicated. The issues raised by Stoll, and expanded on by Kornfield, show how competent we must be when it comes to dealing with governments, with capitalists, with Marxists, and with tribal peoples. In addition to checking our empire building, we must ruthlessly scrutinize the quality of the people we send out to fish for us.

Every serious fisherman knows that skill and experience pay off in more catches. There’s a huge difference between the fisherman who slogs through the middle of a creek, slashing lures left and right, and the careful angler who studies the water and the insect hatch and then deftly launches his cast from a well-obscured position.

Missionaries today cannot afford to presume that fishing for men demands anything less than the best possible training. Their skills must be razor sharp. Those skills go beyond the typical missions course. To fish in today’s world requires broad knowledge of human affairs and the issues that lie beneath the surface of the pond. Each nation, each tribe, each people is a unique configuration of social pressures. The conclusions offered by William Kornfield indicate the breadth of knowledge and experience required.

Let’s seize the opportunity to open ourselves to God’s criticism. We are accountable to him, not to human authors. But they can be used for our good, if we are willing to back off and inspect both our fishing and our empire building.

—–

Copyright © 2006 Evangelism and Missions Information Service (EMIS). All rights reserved. Not to be reproduced or copied in any form without written permission from EMIS.

GoToOlder PostNewer PostAll PostsArticlesEMQSectionVolume 19 - Issue 4

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to Our Mailing List

Keep up to date with our community.

Menu

  • Home
  • Directories
  • Advertise
  • Donate
  • Contact Us

Join

  • Join
  • Benefits
  • Learn
  • Meet
  • Engage

Help

  • Contact Us
  • Terms
  • Cookies Policy

About Us

  • Who We Are
  • Statement of Faith
  • Awards
  • Resources
Missio Nexus Logo

© Missio Nexus. All rights reserved.
As an Amazon Associate Missio Nexus earns from qualifying purchases.


PO Box 398
Wheaton, IL 60187-0398

Phone: 770.457.6677
678.392.4577

Annual Sponsors

ECFA Logo Brotherhood Mutual Logo

Subscribe to our Mailing List

Membership website powered by MembershipWorks